arrow_downarrow_leftarrow_rightarrow_upbookmarkArtboard 6bubbleicon_arrow_lefticon_birdicon_calicon_facebookicon_mailicon_searchicon_twittericon_websiteicon-emailicon-facebookicon-ldicon-twitterArtboard 6review_countsigthumbs_downthumbs_uptop_allArtboard 6top_yearw-negw-nonew-nutw-pos

The Three Musketeers

May 18th - October 19thFestival TheatreTicket Info
Generally Mixed Reviews based on 15 Critics
15 Reviews

Traditional arts journalism is in decline. Now more than ever, this independent website and our podcast fill a growing void. We've had over 1.5 million page views, and are grateful that you are here. We rely on readers — and a handful of advertisers who share our values — to make our work possible. When we raised funds for our podcast, The "Performers Podcast," the average donation from people like you was $96. Now we hope you’ll join us in augmenting our coverage of arts in the region by making a one-time donation today.

Founder Stratford Festival Reviews
Donate Now
This is a listing for the 2013 season. For the current 2023 shows click here.

The American Conservative - Noah Millman

Magnificent swordplay, lively and...

“The swordplay really is magnificent – kudos to fight director John Stead. And the cast is lively and amiable…But while the plot is copious, is it really compelling? How much flavor does this old chestnut still have?”

Read Full Review

The Globe and Mail - J. Kelly Nestruck

Overstays its welcome like a summer...

“Every second scene in the first half seems to end with the heroes touching swords and crying “One for all, and all for one!”, a predecessor of action-movie catchphrases like “May the Force be with you…Like the summer blockbusters of today, The Three Musketeers overstays its welcome by an hour or so.”

Read Full Review

The Record - Robert Reid

Busy and bustling, yet tedious

The bustling production is “told through a convoluted plot that unfolds in swift, episodic fashion”, but the production was “tedious”: “It failed to engage my imagination and I soon became weary of it all.” Reid gives kudos to Jonathan Goad who “steals the show whenever he is on stage.”

Read Full Review

The London Free Press - John Coulbourn

Strong start, but lost steam

Coulbourn found Potter’s adaptation of “The Three Musketeers” began “in pretty smashing fashion…But the trip is barely underway and young D’Artagnan’s voyage begins to lose steam as Potter struggles to keep the theatrical action-adventure ball in the air and all eyes upon it.”

Read Full Review

The Toronto Star - Richard Ouzounian

More like a sitcom than a play

Ouzounian notes most of the Stratford production “is played at such a broadly sitcom level that instead of calling it The Three Musketeers it really should have been billed as Three’s Company”. He believed The Three Musketeers themselves were strong performers, with [Luke] Humphrey giving “The best solution”.

Read Full Review

Detroit Free Press - John Monaghan

Live theatre meets summer blockbuster

Monaghan calls the sword fighting “solidly executed, silly in the style of ‘The Princess Bride’ or ‘Pirates of the Caribbean'”. He states “the play has the power to give you the same thrill you had when getting involved in your first adventure book” at any age.

Read Full Review

The National Post - Robert Cushman

Robert Cushman

In Cushman’s review of multiple shows, Cushman called “Tommy” thrilling despite what he calls the “sickly piece of rock-hero mythology” libretto. He thought “The Three Musketeers” sacrificed humour for plot details.

Read Full Review

Calgary Herald - Jamie Portman

McKenna succeeds, Musketeers lack...

Portman focuses on “Mary Stuart”, “Blithe Spirit” and “The Three Musketeers”. He praises “Cimolino’s gripping vision and Peter Oswald’s sizzling new translation.” He found very little” enjoyment in The Three Musketeers and “some surprising moments of unnecessary brutality.” Portman gives kudos to McKenna’s roles such as “a performance of dotty perfection as Madame Arcati”.

Read Full Review

The Hamilton Spectator - Gary Smith

Needs a strong directorial vision

“You can either approach this swashbuckling story as a high-flown romance, or you can tramp it into the dust as a foolish little farce. What you can’t do, however, is try to do a bit of both.” Smith praises the score, set design, lighting, costumes and male leads.

Read Full Review

Stratford Gazette - Chet Greason

Connects heroes of yesterday and today

Greason states director Raby’s “notes in the program even mention the likes of Batman and the villainous Voldemort, drawing parallels between the swashbuckling heroes of yesterday and today.” He praises the quick scene changes, but notes “audience members with contemporary views of sexual equality may find [Milady] problematic.”

Read Full Review

The Beat Magazine - Geoff Dale

Long on talk and short on action

“The opening sequence featuring some wonderful no-holds-barred swordplay between a boisterous young D’Artagnan (Luke Humphrey) and his well-skilled father (played by Wayne Best) gives one the impression this could be a swashbuckler for the ages. Sadly, such is not the case. The story proceeds at an often tedious pace.”

Read Full Review

Robyn's Reviews - RL Godfrey

"Musketeers" cast swashes buckles...

Godfrey reviews both “The Three Musketeers” and “Blithe Spirit”. She found Abbey’s performance lacked depth and Shara’s portrayal “nearly foppy”.However,she liked seeing Goad “have such fun” with his character in “The Three Musketeers”. She felt Topham “has never been better” than her role as Ruth in “The Blithe Spirit”.

Read Full Review

Stage Door - Christopher Hoile

Unsuitable as a children's play

Hoile understood children would like “The Three Musketeers” because of D’Artagan’s triumph and “the good-versus-evil plot”. However, he notes the narrative’s details “reveal complexities in morality and narrative that would respectively puzzle and bore most children, and indeed most adults.

Read Full Review

The Charlebois Post-Canada - Stuart Munro

Musketeers have undeniable chemistry

Munro states the chemistry between Humphrey and “the other musketeers is undeniable, and goes a long way to making this production the successful romp that it is”. He found Goad’s entrance “hilarious”, Shara “successfully treads the fine line between swordsman and man of God”, and Abbey ” provides the necessary depth”.

Read Full Review

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - Mike Fischer

Thematic unity no accident

Fischer finds common themes in the various productions he saw, including “Tommy”, “Fiddler on the Roof”, “Waiting For Godot” and a preview of “Taking Shakespeare”. He notes “Cimolino has succeeded, spectacularly — allowing plays written and set centuries apart to speak to each other and to us in new ways.”

Read Full Review

No Matches for Reviews

Share This Post:

Share This Tweet This Email This